In Praise of Bewilderment

A few years ago, I began a large culture evolution engagement with a national organization. The scope was significant. There were multiple business units across several locations, long-standing values interpreted in conflicting ways, competing narratives about what “success” really meant, and a CEO who knew the current culture wouldn’t carry them through their next strategic plan.

In one of our early progress conversations, I shared something confidentially that surprised us both.

“The work is going well. And right now, it feels bewildering.”

He paused, smiled, and said, “Good.”

We both understood why.

We were entering terrain where quick fixes and tidy frameworks wouldn’t solve the complex and very human challenges and opportunities. The complexity demanded humility, investigation, time, deep thinking, and care. Naming that reality grounded us. It kept us honest.

The Wild Inside the Word

The word bewildered comes from the root wild. Originally, it meant to be led into the wilds — to lose the familiar path in the forest.

Today, we use it to mean ‘confused’ or ‘perplexed.’ But its older meaning is more instructive. Bewilderment is what happens when the known map runs out.

Leadership inevitably brings us to the unknown. A company vision is an imagined destination. Our business strategy has yet to be realized. Growth exposes unknown territory. Strategy outpaces our known culture.

When the old path fades, and the way forward is not yet clear, that is where the real work begins.

When Not Knowing Signals Depth and Opportunity

Wendell Berry writes:

“It may be that when we no longer know what to do we have come to our real work, and that when we no longer know which way to go we have come to our real journey. The mind that is not baffled is not employed. The impeded stream is the one that sings.”

When leaders reach the edge of their existing answers, attention sharpens, listening deepens, and curiosity replaces assumption.

In that culture engagement, we resisted the urge to rush toward resolution. We listened widely and deeply in town halls, focus groups, small-group sessions, surveys, and one-on-one conversations. We named what had gone unspoken. We examined visible behaviors and the underlying beliefs shaping them. We unearthed the invisible culture through deep noticing.

As we stayed with the complexity, patterns revealed themselves. Solutions surfaced that were more grounded, more relevant to where they were headed, and more durable because they arose from within the system itself.

Wonder as Strength

Bewilderment can open the door to wonder: a steady, disciplined curiosity in the face of ambiguity.

Or, if we rush it, it can calcify into defensiveness and premature certainty.

There were intense moments in that engagement. As old dynamics surfaced and identities shifted, discomfort rose and was addressed with care. Clarity brought relief and confusion in equal measure. That’s often the nature of real change.

Remaining present through that discomfort is part of leadership.

The Threshold of Transformation

In mythology, the wilderness is a threshold. It’s a place where familiar, fixed identities loosen and something deeper, more integrated begins to form.

Organizations move through similar thresholds. Strategic pivots, a new vision, mergers, market shifts, and leadership changes can each usher leaders into uncertain terrain.

When leaders stay grounded — steady in themselves, clear in their values, open-hearted in their listening — bewilderment becomes generative. It deepens insight. It strengthens collaboration. It cultivates humility.

The impeded stream is the one that sings.

I have to admit, I celebrate being bewildered, at least for a short while. I realize it’s a vital stage of my work, as I deal with the complexity of serving teams and leaders. This phase is a catalyst to evolve a culture, brand, or strategy. So, if your work feels bewildering right now, take solace. You may be closer to meaningful transformation than you think. The absence of easy answers frequently indicates that you are no longer skimming the surface — you are engaging what actually matters.

And in leadership, as in life, that is where the most enduring outcomes emerge.

If you want a more trusting team, a culture of belonging or a magnetic brand that attracts more of the right customers, I can help. If you'd like to explore if working together makes sense, drop me a line.

Let’s Talk >