The Useful Opponent
In 1587, the Vatican formalized one of history’s more unusual assignments: arguing against saints.
Before a candidate could be canonized, an official called the Promotor Fidei assembled the case against them. He questioned miracles, challenged witnesses, and searched for whatever admiration had encouraged others to overlook. History remembers the role by its more colorful name: the Devil’s Advocate.
The instinct was sound. When everyone in the room wants the same answer, fewer people keep looking for a better one.
UC Berkeley psychologist Charlan Nemeth tested whether the Vatican’s fix actually works. In her study she compared people exposed to authentic dissent against three separate versions of assigned devil’s advocacy. Every devil’s advocate condition lost. The authentic dissenter generated more original solutions, prompted deeper consideration of the opposing view, and produced real attitude change. None of the role-players came close, no matter how the role was set up.
When we set aside our confirmation bias, our instincts can tell the difference between a person who means it and a person who’s been handed a role to play. One changes how people think. The other (mostly) makes them defend what they already believed, more elaborately.
That doesn’t retire three tools built for exactly this problem.
A red team assigns a team or individual to attack your plan the way a competitor would, hunting for every seam.
A pre-mortem asks the team to imagine the project has already failed, a year out, and reconstruct exactly how.
In my “Put Us Out of Business” workshops, a leadership team spends an afternoon becoming its own most dangerous competitor: stealing its own customers, poaching its own best people, borrowing its process and methods, etc.
What Nemeth’s finding tells you is what these tools are actually good for, and it isn’t what most leaders assume.
A leadership team was two hours into a pre-mortem workshop when I asked each person to become the competitor for twenty minutes. Full license to want the company gone, using what we know about our business, that could be used against us. An operations lead who’d sat mostly silent through multiple planning meetings said, in character: “I’d go straight at their marketing under-spend. Everyone in the building knows we don’t invest enough in our marketing, and nobody’s fixed it.”
The room went uncomfortably quiet. People squirmed uncomfortably for a minute, until one person spoke up saying, “here, here!” Then the real meeting started.
That sentence had been orbiting the team all year. She added, “our marketing is dangerously underinvested in.” At the follow-up meeting, the finance director questioned why she hadn’t raised it sooner. As the competitor, the sentence costs nothing. The insight was undeniably dangerous to the organization, but the exposure to the individual wasn’t.
That’s what a pre-mortem (or red team) actually rents out: temporary cover for candor.
Research on the technique shows that imagining an outcome as already real, rather than merely possible, makes people substantially better at naming its true causes, something close to a 30 percent improvement over simply asking what might go wrong. Nobody in the room disagrees with anybody. Everybody enters one fiction together and reports back what they found there.
The catch: the air cover only holds while the exercise is running. A team can spend an afternoon attacking its own plan in character and walk back into the office the next morning defending it exactly as before, the marketing investment comment already filed under “good exercise” rather than “known problem” that actually gets addressed.
A better process is preverbal. Ask people to write down their concerns independently before the loudest, most powerful, and confident voices sway or silence the room. The most senior people in the room should speak last. Yes, run the red team, the pre-mortem, the competitor role-play, whatever gets the concerns onto paper. Then ask the question that turns an exercise back into a meaningful and actionable conversation:
“Which of these do you personally believe?”
“Of these concerns, which are we least willing to admit to ourselves?”
“What’s at stake if we don’t solve these concerns?”
Pause there. Let it sit.
Someone may name the marketing investment issue. The deadline nobody thinks is realistic. The customer complaint that’s been subtly re-categorized as a marketing problem. The founder’s favorite initiative that everyone else has learned to walk on eggshells around.
What the leader does next teaches the room what happens to a real concern.
I’ve seen this take one of two paths.
Defend the plan on the spot, and people will learn to bring only the safe version next time.
Or ask fierce, honest questions, sit with the discomfort, and make the necessary changes when the evidence calls for them. In doing so, disagreement becomes something the organization actually uses to its own benefit.
A useful opponent can extend beyond simply assigning Devil’s Advocate role-playing. It can take the form of someone who cares enough about the outcome to risk the room’s approval to improve it, and a leader steady enough to hear that without hearing disloyalty.
Run the exercises. Borrow the competitor’s eyes. Speak truth to power and your own blind spots. Imagine the failure before it happens.
Then find out whether anyone in the room will say the same sentence again, unmasked, in their own voice.
If you found this topic interesting or valuable, here are some related articles for you.
If you want a more trusting team, a culture of belonging or a magnetic brand that attracts more of the right customers, I can help. If you'd like to explore if working together makes sense, drop me a line.
